Carl McGlasson West Cumbria
6 live Book a call

Guide 03 · Reviews

Google reviews: how to get more, reply well and stay inside the law

Reviews are the strongest trust signal on your profile and one of the few ranking factors Google confirms. They’re also now regulated by UK law. Here’s how to build them the right way.

Reviews do two jobs at once. They persuade the person reading your profile, and they tell Google you’re a real, active, well-regarded business. Google says outright that review count and score factor into local ranking. Very few things in local SEO come with that kind of confirmation.

But the rules have changed. Since April 2025 fake reviews have been illegal in the UK, and in 2026 Google tightened its own policies and got much better at catching people who break them. The methods that used to work are now a liability. Here’s what works now.

Why reviews matter more than ever

  • Ranking. Google’s help page says more reviews and positive ratings can improve your local ranking.
  • Clicks. Customers compare star ratings and review counts in the map pack before they compare anything else.
  • AI answers. Google’s AI summaries in Maps and Search draw on what reviewers write about you. Reviews that describe the actual job give the AI something specific to say.
  • Trust. A business with 140 reviews averaging 4.8 feels safe. A business with 6 feels like a gamble, however good it really is.

The content matters as much as the stars. “Great, thanks” helps a little. “They did an end of tenancy clean on our three-bed in Workington and we got the full deposit back” helps a lot: it names the service, the place and the result.

The rules: Google’s and the law’s

There are two rulebooks now, and you need to follow both.

UK law: the DMCC Act

The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 brought in a specific ban on fake reviews, which came into force on 6 April 2025. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) can now enforce it directly and fine businesses up to 10% of global turnover. Under the Act, these are banned outright:

  • Writing, commissioning or buying fake reviews, positive or negative
  • Reviews that hide the fact they were incentivised
  • Presenting reviews in a misleading way, for example only showing the good ones while implying they’re all of them

Businesses that publish reviews, including on their own website, must also take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews. The CMA’s guidance (CMA208) says that means having a clear, published policy banning fake reviews and explaining your approach to incentivised ones. When the CMA checked more than 100 business websites after the law came in, it found more than half could be falling short.

If you show reviews on your website, add a short reviews policy page. It takes ten minutes and puts you ahead of most of your competitors.

Google’s rules

Google’s policy is stricter than the law. It bans:

  • Offering anything in exchange for a review: discounts, prize draws, free extras
  • Asking only happy customers (review gating)
  • Reviews from staff, owners, family or anyone with a conflict of interest
  • Reviewing competitors
  • Since April 2026: asking customers to mention a particular staff member by name, and requiring or pressuring customers to leave a review while they’re still on your premises, such as handing them a tablet at the till

Google enforces this at scale. In its 2025 report it said it blocked or removed more than 292 million reviews that broke its rules. If it spots a sudden spike in suspicious reviews it can now remove them, pause new reviews on your profile, and show customers a banner explaining why. That banner is far more damaging than having fewer reviews.

The staff-name rule caught a lot of businesses out, including ones that meant well. Plenty of cleaning and trade companies used to say “please mention Sarah in your review”. Now that’s exactly what Google tells you not to do. Ask for an honest review and let customers mention whoever they like.

How to get more reviews, legitimately

The businesses with the most reviews aren’t the ones with the happiest customers. They’re the ones that ask every time, at the right moment, with no friction.

In your Business Profile, choose “Ask for reviews” (or “Get more reviews”) to copy a short link that opens the review box directly. Save it everywhere: your phone, your invoicing software, your email signature.

2. Ask at the moment of delight

The best moment is when the customer has just seen the result: the finished room, the delivered laundry, the keys handed back. A message within an hour of finishing a job gets far more reviews than one sent a week later.

3. Make it personal and short

A text from the person who did the job works better than an automated email. Something like:

“Hi Jane, thanks for having us today. If you’ve got a minute, an honest Google review really helps a small local business like ours: [link]. Thanks, Carl”

No pressure, no incentive, no script for what to write.

4. Build it into the process

Make the review request a step in the job, not a favour you remember occasionally. Put it in your job-completion checklist, add the link to the invoice, include it in the follow-up email, and put a QR code on the leave-behind card. Customers can scan it later at home, which keeps you clear of the on-premises rule.

5. Ask everyone, the same way

Every customer gets the same request. If one is unhappy, you want to know, and you’d far rather fix it before they write anything.

How to reply to reviews

Reply to every review, good and bad, within a few days. Replies are public, so you’re writing for the next hundred customers as much as for the reviewer.

Positive reviews: thank them by name, mention the service naturally, and keep it short. “Thanks Jane, glad the end of tenancy clean went well and you got your deposit back. Good luck in the new place.” Don’t copy and paste the same reply to every review.

Negative reviews: this is where you win or lose customers.

  1. Wait until you’re calm. Never reply angry.
  2. Thank them for the feedback and acknowledge the problem without arguing.
  3. Explain briefly what happened or what you’ve changed, without sharing private details.
  4. Take it offline: invite them to call or email you directly.
  5. If you fix it, they may update the review. Don’t ask them to delete it.

A fair, professional reply to a one-star review often does more for your reputation than another five-star one. People know no business is perfect. They’re watching how you handle it.

When you can get a review removed

You can report a review from your profile if it breaks Google’s rules: it’s fake, it’s from someone who was never a customer, it’s spam, it’s abusive, it reveals personal information, or it’s about the wrong business. Gather any evidence you have, such as no record of the person in your bookings.

You can’t get a review removed because it’s negative, unfair or inaccurate in your view. And be careful: in September 2026 Google added a policy on “misuse of support channels”. Reporting legitimate reviews over and over, or filing complaints without evidence, can get your future reports ignored.

Reviews on your own website

Show your best reviews on your website too. They help visitors who arrive from ads or other searches, and Google reportedly now asks some Maps users to sign in to see all of a business’s reviews, so your own site is a reliable place to display them.

If you do, follow the DMCC rules: don’t cherry-pick in a misleading way, link to the full set on Google, and publish your reviews policy. If you use a widget that pulls reviews from Google automatically, you’re showing them as they are, which is the safest approach.

A simple review system for a small business

  • Direct review link saved on every phone and in your invoicing tool
  • Review request sent within an hour of every finished job
  • QR code on leave-behind cards and invoices
  • Every customer asked the same way, with no incentive and no script
  • Notifications on, and every review answered within three days
  • Reviews policy published on your website
  • Monthly check: review count and average against your top three competitors

Run that every week and reviews stop being something you worry about. They just build. Next, the less glamorous signal that sits behind them: business citations in the UK.

Sources: CMA: Fake reviews guidance (CMA208); Google: How to improve your local ranking; Google: Maps user-generated content policy.

Carl McGlasson, with his signature

Written by

Carl McGlasson

I run Cumbria Bright, Zippy Bright and Osiyo Stays in West Cumbria, and build websites and AI systems through Pervonio. Everything in these guides comes from running those businesses, with the rules and figures checked against the official sources.

Spotted something out of date, or want help putting it into practice? Get in touch.

Quick answers

What people ask next.

01Is it legal to offer a discount for a Google review?

Under UK law, incentivised reviews must be clearly disclosed or they’re banned. But Google’s own rules go further and prohibit offering anything in exchange for a review, so on Google the answer is simply don’t.

02Can I ask only my happy customers for reviews?

No. Filtering customers so only happy ones are sent to Google, often called review gating, breaks Google’s policy. Ask every customer in the same way.

03Can I get a bad Google review removed?

Only if it breaks Google’s rules, for example if it’s fake, from someone who was never a customer, offensive, or about a different business. You can report it from your profile. A review that’s simply negative and honest stays, so the best response is a calm, public reply.

04How many Google reviews do I need?

There’s no magic number. What matters is having more recent, genuine reviews than the businesses you compete with, and a steady flow rather than a burst. Look at the top three in your area and aim to beat them over the next six months.

05Should I reply to every Google review?

Yes, good and bad. Replies show customers the business is run by people who care, and they let you add context, like the specific service, that helps both customers and Google understand what you do.